A woman in a black cap and polo shirt, notebook and pens in hand, makes a point to a man with his back to the camera on the lawn of an ivy-covered country house.
Photograph: Adam Paylor, 2016.
Home  /  Articles  /  Why stakeholder conflict comes as a surprise
Insights · Stakeholder mapping

Why stakeholder conflict comes as a surprise

Most stakeholder conflict starts in the parts of the picture that the plan leaves out.

Anthony SharmanNovember 20265 min read

Stakeholder management is usually based on assumptions about bilateral relationships between a strategy and a stakeholder. The map, the grid and the engagement plan each take one stakeholder at a time and ask what they want from the strategy, how much influence they have over it and how they should be kept informed. Every line on the page runs between the strategy and one name.

The real world is much more complex and multipolar. Stakeholders deal with each other as well as with you, and most stakeholder conflict starts in the parts of the picture that the plan leaves out. That is why it so often comes as a surprise to people who did the stakeholder analysis properly.

Why does stakeholder conflict happen?

Stakeholders and their agendas exist in tension with each other. The tension was there before your strategy arrived and it will be there afterwards.

  • CFO and COO. One is watching cost and cash; the other needs capacity to deliver.
  • Growth shareholders and income shareholders. One wants profit reinvested; the other wants it paid out.
  • Risk managers and budget managers. One is looking to minimise risk; the other cost.
  • Regulators and entrepreneurs. One is there to be satisfied before anything moves; the other needs to move before a competitor does.

Each of these people is doing the job they are there to do, and each may well support your strategy when you speak to them alone. Put the same decision to two of them and one stakeholder’s support can become the other’s objection. A stakeholder map can score both as supporters without any inkling of the tension between them.

Do stakeholder groups speak with one voice?

The stakeholder groups you make assumptions about can themselves be more complex, based on sub-divisions with different agendas. “The board”, “the council”, “the customer” and “the workforce” are labels of convenience. A council is elected members and officers. A customer is a procurement team, a budget holder and the people who will use what you deliver. A workforce includes people a year from retirement and people a year into the job.

An engagement plan written for the label will suit some of the people behind it and miss the rest. The disagreement that follows looks like a stakeholder changing their mind, when the group never held a single view in the first place.

How can you explore stakeholder conflict before it happens?

Role-playing and exercising is an effective way to explore some of this nuance. Give the people round the table a stakeholder each to play, with a short brief on what that stakeholder wants and what they are worried about. Then put a decision in front of them in a scenario: a budget cut, a launch date, a site closure.

People playing a role argue its corner harder than anyone does when filling in a column headed “interests”. Whoever is playing the finance director objects to what the operations director’s player has just agreed. Someone playing the regulator asks a question the team had not prepared for. Split a stakeholder group between two players with different briefs and the sub-divisions show up as well. The tensions between stakeholders are now being voiced by people, where before they were being assumed on paper.

What can you do with a conflict once it is in the open?

Flushing out conflict allows for some planning to overcome it. Ideas can be had within an exercise and captured for development into contingency plans for concessions or compromise.

When two stakeholders collide in an exercise, the players usually start negotiating there and then: what one could give up, what the other would accept, who would need to hear about it first. Those ideas are worth writing down as they are spoken. Afterwards they can be worked up properly alongside the stakeholder tools: which concessions you would be prepared to offer and in what order, and where a compromise is possible. Some conflicts will turn out to be dilemmas, where every option carries a cost for somebody, and those are better recognised early than discovered on the day.

Can an exercise predict stakeholder conflict?

An exercise won’t predict exactly what will happen, but it is a much more effective way to explore complexity than just filling out a template. The people playing the roles are not the stakeholders, and the real CFO may still surprise you. What the team gains is experience of stakeholders in tension with each other, practice at responding, and a few concessions already thought through.

Some form of rehearsal beats any number of optimistic assumptions.

The stakeholder map is still worth drawing. It tells you who has a stake in the strategy and how much weight they carry. Read as a list of separate relationships, it will leave you surprised. Read as a set of people who also have to deal with each other, it prompts a more useful question: which two of your stakeholders have never had to face the same decision together?

Frequently asked questions

What is an example of stakeholder conflict?

A finance director who needs costs held and an operations director who needs to spend on capacity can both back the same strategy while still opposing each other over the first budget decision it produces. The same tension exists between growth and income shareholders, between risk managers and budget managers, and between regulators and developers.

What is the difference between stakeholder conflict and a conflict of interest?

A conflict of interest sits with one person who has two loyalties. Stakeholder conflict sits between people or groups whose agendas pull against each other, and it can equally sit inside a group that looked like a single stakeholder.

How do you resolve stakeholder conflict?

Usually through concession or compromise, and both are easier when they have been thought through beforehand. An exercise lets a team find the likely conflicts and draft contingency plans while there is still time to choose between them.

Can a stakeholder map show conflict?

Only in part. A map shows each stakeholder’s interest in your strategy and their influence over it. It does not show how stakeholders relate to each other, or the divisions inside a stakeholder group. Role-playing the stakeholders against a real decision adds what the map leaves out.

Bring it to your team

Give your people a learning experience, not a lecture

Every Evocatus programme is built around the work your team actually does, and designed to work towards a debrief that ensures you get maximum value from your time and resource.

Explore what we do